The student news site of Linfield University

The Linfield Review

The student news site of Linfield University

The Linfield Review

The student news site of Linfield University

The Linfield Review

Don’t judge a book by its prize

Along with its many other useful — and not so useful — functions, Facebook is nothing if not an accurate tap on student life. Whether it’s regarding the latest campus debauchery or last night’s episode of “The Office,” the tones of status updates usually correctly measure the pulse of opinions on these issues.
The same is true for national events.
True to form, when it was announced that President Obama had been awarded the Nobel Peace Prize on Oct. 9, Linfield students were quick to chime in on the matter via online posts
Their reactions more or less reflect that of the larger U.S. society and demonstrate yet again how polarized politics in this country have become.
According to a story on the CNN Web site, Obama’s supporters see the award as well deserved; his critics, however, say he has done nothing to earn the title and that it represents his skewed popularity abroad. The prize, after all, is awarded by a Swedish foundation.
Similarly, some Linfield students praised Obama for the accomplishment. Others complained that the Nobel Committee has forgotten its standards and begun to just hand out its awards. Others pointed out that nominations for the prize were due just 10 days after Obama was inaugurated. All were, pleasantly or not, surprised.
This award has indeed seemed to fuel the fire for those who believe Obama is under-qualified for the position of president at all.
One fact unites this variety of viewpoints: Obama has a long way to go.
In fact, he has the majority of his term to prove himself, and this is his stated intent.
As Americans, we should step back and see if this “call to action” is truly answered before we write off his deservingness.
After all, the change he promised in his campaign was never portrayed as a quick fix. His long-term goals can’t be forgotten.
The Nobel Committee cited its decision as one based on Obama’s “extraordinary efforts to strengthen international diplomacy and cooperation between peoples.”
Even though his name was considered long before his policies regarding Afghanistan, North Korea and Cuba were officially announced, isn’t diplomacy at the center of these foreign policy decisions?
The effectiveness of these policies is yet to be seen, but the effort is there, and it is on this effort that Obama was judged.
In the words of an Arizona State University representative, spoken after the school refused to award Obama an honorary degree after he delivered its commencement address last spring, “The body of his work is yet to come.”
Was the honor premature? Maybe. It’s too soon to tell.
From here, Obama has a long road to travel. As students, and by extension informed citizens, we need to clear the path before we pass judgment on the committee’s decision.

The Review Editorial Board

3
View Comments (3)
More to Discover

Comments (3)

All The Linfield Review Picks Reader Picks Sort: Newest

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • M

    Mark JohnsonOct 19, 2009 at 8:46 pm

    “All Nobel Prizes are awarded in Stockholm, Sweden, except for the Nobel Peace Prize, which is awarded in Oslo, Norway. The founder of the Nobel Prize, Alfred Nobel, was a Swedish cosmopolitan. In his will, he declared that the Nobel Peace Prize should be awarded by a Norwegian committee.”

    http://nobelprize.org/nobel_prizes/peace/shortfacts.html

    Reply
  • D

    dbaezOct 19, 2009 at 12:27 pm

    Mr. Johnson,

    Just to prevent any further confusion on the matter, while the Nobel Prize Prize and its recipients’ lectures ARE presented at the annual Prize Award Ceremony in Oslo, Norway, the foundation itself is based in Sweden (http://nobelprize.org/nobelfoundation/contact.html), which is what we commented on in this editorial.

    Dominic Baez
    Editor in chief

    Reply
  • M

    Mark JohnsonOct 16, 2009 at 4:22 pm

    A. Its Norway…small mistake, speaks volumes.
    B. The prize should be given for what IS done, not what MIGHT be done in the future. Your editorial reeks of defensivness about Obama ‘planning’ on doing things. Great. I plan on owning a Microsoft in three years.
    C. Hilter, Stalin Mussolini were also nominees.
    D. “extraordinary efforts to strengthen….cooperation between peoples” I’m sure the growing number of Republicans, independents AND Democrats would not agree with this as Obama’s efforts within his own country have, HAVE been divisive and render people to question government. Fact, not opinion.

    Reply